photo

Book

book cover

The Trouble With Islam Today: A Muslim's Call for Reform in Her Faith. Published in almost 30 countries and languages.

Learn More

Buy the US paperback
Amazon | Barnes & Noble

Audio Book

Audio Book

The Trouble With Islam Today. Read in English by Irshad Manji, with music by Deeyah and Gary Justice.

Buy Now

Free Translations

For where the book is difficult to access, censored or banned:

button
button
button_lang button button

Archives

Giving thanks is no heresy, you turkeys

Posted in Irshaddering Thoughts on Oct 08, 2007

In Canada, it’s Thanksgiving Day. You’d think that all people of faith would welcome a semi-spiritual moment in the West’s calendar.

But how does one Toronto-area mosque reportedly recognize this most harmless, even honourable, of holidays? By telling Muslims that we’re kuffar if we participate in Thanksgiving greetings and dinners.

Apart from being mean-spirited and absurd, this decree is highly ironic. After all, etymologically speaking, “kuffar” refers to someone who’s ungrateful to God.

So think about it: If we express gratitude to God on Thanksgiving, we’re kuffar - ungrateful to God. Huh? How does that work?

As I said in a recent radio interview, teachings like these only feed off the ignorance of newly arrived Muslim communities. We should question our imams and civic leaders. I, for one, am grateful that I’ve taken the opportunity to educate myself, which is a privilege we enjoy in free societies.

Tonight, as I break my fast, I’ll be praying that more of us Muslims distinguish between education and indoctrination. Ameen and pass the gravy, please.

Bookmark and Share AddThis Feed Button

Documentary

dvd cover

Irshad's PBS Documentary: Faith Without Fear follows my journey around the world to reconcile Islam and freedom.

Learn More and View Clips...

Buy Now in the USA
Buy Now in Canada

Get Involved

photo

Irshad is pioneering efforts throughout the world to promote Muslim reform and moral courage. To join her mission, first get informed about all that she's doing.

Click here for concrete actions you can take to support Irshad's work.

Get Updates

Want to know more about what Irshad's doing? Sign up to her confidential mailing list.

Click here to see an archive of Irshad's previous newsletters.