Archives

Should the burqa be banned in a free society?

Posted in Irshaddering Thoughts, Q & A on Oct 10, 2009

London, UK (Photo: M. Douglas)

A few days ago, I sent this message to my Facebook fans: “France is currently debating whether to ban the burqa and veil. Now, my own country of Canada is debating that, too. A **Muslim** group is calling on the Canadian government to outlaw the burqa. How do you think the government should respond?”

Twenty-four hours later, I re-visited my fan page. Hello! I found more responses to this question than to just about anything I’ve ever posted.  Equally revealing, Muslims are disagreeing with each other.

Male versus female, you ask?  In a sense, yes. In my Facebook community, Muslim men are likely to reject the burqa outright while Muslim women are inclined to support choice.

Here’s a sample of their arguments, peppered with interventions from non-Muslims who have experience with Muslim societies:

* “Burqa? This hideous thing should most definitely be banned.”  - Umar

* “The GOVERNMENT should not have a say over whether a woman can wear it or not. If they did, they would be no different from Saudi Arabia or any other country that forces women to wear it.” - Sara

* “Yes, ban the burqa. A woman’s head is not an extension of her private parts.  A woman in burqa is convinced she is a a giant pussy on legs.  This is  offensive. Burqa is also dangerous. Not different from seeing a man walking down the street wearing a Ku Klux Klan hood, or a skinhead with a tattoo of a swastika on his forehead.” - Azhar

* “I wear the hijab on my head and I live in America. I would fight with the government til the end on something like this. Who cares what people wear as long as they are not doing anything wrong to you?” - Diana

* “One of my best friends is Muslimah and she lived in Algeria for years, never wearing a veil, never being asked to wear it.  As soon as her family moves to the States, her father, who is quite secular in Algeria, tries to impose the veil on his daughters. Why? Because in his eyes, they’re living in a hostile nation, and he needs to protect his daughters from the eyes of infidel boys/men.  My friend resisted and used the Quran as her justification. But her others sisters veiled, to keep the peace, because of their abusive dad.” - Rodney

* “The burqa is a marketing tool for Islamists. In a day and age when Islamist criminality is worldwide, the burqa is not an option!” - Najat

* “Sure, there have been security problems in countries with men hiding under burqas and niqabs. But I have also been witness to a woman being harassed by security in the middle of Khan Al Khalili, a very busy market in the middle of Cairo. Banned or unbanned, it is still Muslim women who are the victims here. Banning a style of dress will not ensure extra security for anyone.” - Sue

* “In the Middle East, a woman wearing burqa who was allowed to drive almost hit me because she couldn’t see me!” - Rosa

* “I don’t agree with [a] country imposing a certain dress code. Who the hell are you? If they want to ban it, ban it all. That means the nuns can’t wear what they wear.  A Christian can’t wear a cross, a Jewish man can’t wear a kippah, and all other religious symbols should be banned too.” - Faisal

* “Irshad, the other day, with horror, I saw a WalkingBurqa in The Eaton Centre [Toronto shopping mall].  I told my daughter to forget about the shopping and let’s get the hell out of here. U never know what’s inside the WalkingBurqa.  Canadian government should ban it… ASAP.” - Rehmatullah

Now I’m asking my Facebook community to interpret the photo at the very top of this post. Snapped in London recently, the picture shows three burqa-clad women walking the same footpath as a woman in a tank top and skirt.

How do you interpret this image? What does it say to you?

Join the conversation, and many more to come, on  my Facebook fan page.